Hello dear
Welcome to West New York Pizza
West New York Pizza, located at 5404 Park Ave in West New York, NJ, is quickly becoming the favorite pizza spot for locals. Owned by Vincent, the pizzeria emphasizes high-quality ingredients and traditional techniques, resulting in a truly authentic Jersey pizza experience. Patrons rave about the crispy, well-made dough, balanced sauce, and generous toppings. The menu boasts unique specialty pies, delectable garlic knots, and even delightful pasta dishes. With a friendly atmosphere enhanced by table games, this cozy eatery is perfect for a casual night out. If you're in the area, West New York Pizza is a must-try destination for pizza lovers.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Cheeseburger
FRIED RAVIOLI
Ultimate Insane San Gennaro Pizza
Pizza Cubana
About
West New York Pizza
Welcome to West New York Pizza, where the art of pizza-making is celebrated at its finest. Nestled at 5404 Park Ave, West New York, NJ, this cozy pizzeria is quickly becoming a favorite among locals, and it's easy to see why. The vibrant community atmosphere paired with exceptional food makes it a notable dining destination.
What truly sets West New York Pizza apart is the dedication of its owner, Vincent. From the moment you walk in, it’s clear that passion for quality shines through every pie. Customers rave about the deliciousness of the pizza—like Todd Vander Pas, who describes it as "really damn good," and notes Vincent's commitment to using better ingredients. This emphasis on quality ensures that each bite delivers authentic Jersey flavors.
Those who appreciate a well-crafted crust rejoice at the perfectly crispy pizza dough, as highlighted by Chris Kelsch. The sauce strikes a perfect balance—not overly sweet, reminiscent of traditional Jersey pizza. The cheese is of genuinely high quality, avoiding the rubbery and greasy pitfalls that plague lesser offerings in the area. Add to this a plethora of exciting toppings and special pies, and you have a winning combination that food lovers can't resist.
But it’s not just about the pizza. West New York Pizza promises an enjoyable experience whether you choose to dine in or order delivery. Elissa Erwin praises their reliable delivery service, ensuring that your meal arrives hot and fresh, which reflects their commitment to customer satisfaction.
The ambiance is equally inviting, with friendly servers eager to make your visit memorable. As Peekaboo Cikilymss notes, the establishment is impressively clean and organized. Not just about pizza, their offerings include delightful garlic knots and comforting pasta dishes, rounding out the menu for those seeking variety. For couples like Chris and his wife, the pizzeria also provides table games—a charming touch that elevates their pizza night into a fun, budget-friendly date experience.
In short, West New York Pizza is not just a place to grab a slice; it’s a hub where the community gathers over delicious food. With ten-out-of-ten customer service, delightful dining facets, and remarkable hand-crafted pies, it has firmly established itself as a must-visit for anyone in West New York. So why not stop by, indulge in a slice (or two), and see for yourself what the buzz is all about? You won’t be disappointed!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Really damn good pizza. Vincent, the owner, takes time to make pizza the right way and you can tell that he invests in better ingredients. Our new go to spot for pizza night. ”
“ This place really is the best pizza spot in town. We live right next to the place on park and walk three blocks past that place to get wny pizza. The owner is always there and a really decent dude. The pizza dough is really well made and crispy. Sauce not overly sweet and what makes Jersey pizza good. Cheese is the good kind, not rubbery or greasy. Toppings are plenty and they have some crazy special pies. Called in late towards close and the stayed open late AND made a custom requested pie. They also have table games which always make it fun for my wife and I to get some slices there and have a cheap date. ”
“ The pizza is so fresh and delicious. I love Hawaiian pizza and Garlic knots!! I also order pasta and cake, everything is yummy. Pizza dough is amazing. They just open the restaurant but highly recommend you guys to try! Friendly servers and good price Also the restaurant is so clean and very organize. ... ”
“ The best pizza especially Sicilian style pizza. We adore their other pizzas as well and great fried ravioli. Reliable fast delivery, always hot and fresh! ”
“ Pizza and garlic knots both taste amazing. To top it off the customer service is 10/10. Met the owners and they are very nice people. ”
“ Delicious and fresh pizza ! Very clean! Everybody was very nice and welcoming. It was my last night in New York and I simply could not leave without eating a slice of New York pizza ! ”
“ This is our go to spot whenever we crave New York style pizza and we crave it often. Vinny makes the best rolls. Seen here are the chicken, spinach with ricotta and sausage rolls. The dough is light thin crispy sauce is always on point doesn’t give me heartburn. He doesn’t skimp on the filling either. Restaurant is clean though we usually just take out. The service is attentive even when it is packed and busy. They really make the best tasting pizza in wny. It’s always consistent when Vinny is cheffing it up. ”
“ Slice under carriage is good, crisp is solid, very cheesy, sauce is on point. The garlic knots were soft, garlic flavor was prominent, marinara sauce was nice and sweet/acidic. Perfect dip every time. Family owned since the last few years. The owners greet us when we went and were very hospitable. Would definitely come back here in the future! ”